Polygel vs Soft & Hard Gel: Which is Best for You?

Polygel vs Soft & Hard Gel: If you love getting sculpted nail extensions, you likely know about popular gels like polygel, soft gel and hard gel. But what exactly is the difference between these three gel types?

I’ll explain the unique properties, pros and cons of polygel, soft gel and hard gel. Read on to learn which gel may be best for your nails!

Polygel vs Soft & Hard Gel

Polygel vs Soft & Hard Gel

Polygel, soft gel and hard gel are all polymer gel enhancements that vary in their texture, flexibility, durability and application method.

Polygel is thick like dough, air dries, remains flexible when set, and allows shaping and filing. Soft gel is thickly viscous, cures under lamps in 30-60 seconds, stays flexible, and enables sculpting intricate designs. Hard gel is thin like liquid, cures rigid under lamps in 1-2 minutes, requires no filing after application, and provides maximum durability.

Polygel, soft gel, and hard gel each have unique properties when used for nail enhancements. Here is a quick comparison table summarizing the key differences between the three gel types:

PolygelSoft GelHard Gel
TextureThick, doughyThick, viscousRunny liquid
Curing MethodAir exposureUV/LED lampUV lamp
FlexibilityFlexibleFlexibleRigid
DurabilityModerateLowMaximum
ShapingRequires filingRequires filingNeeds no filing
FinishNaturalHigh-glossThick, durable
Skill LevelBeginnerAdvancedBeginner

 

What Is Hard Gels?

Hard gel has a thin, liquid-like consistency. It remains rigid once fully cured under UV lamps. Hard gel applies smoothly but requires no shaping or filing after application.

Hard gel is prized for its maximum durability and resistance to breaks, chips, and scratches. It cures into an ultra hard finish. While not as suitable for major length, it excels at overlay protection.

Hard Gel Pros

  • Extremely durable and damage resistant
  • Cures into an ultra hard, protective finish
  • Needs no shaping or filing after application
  • Resists scratches, chips, and breaks
  • Great for overlay protection on natural nails
  • Beginner-friendly application

Hard Gel Cons

  • Rigid finish can lead to brittleness over time
  • Gives a thicker, artificial nail appearance
  • Minimal ability to customize shape or length
  • 1-2 minute cure time is slower than other gels
  • No flexibility if impacted – can crack or pop off

If you want maximum protection and durability without much length, hard gel is an ideal choice. The rigid finish withstands damage while protecting your natural nails.

What Is Polygel?

Polygel is a polymer nail gel that has gained huge popularity in recent years. It has a thick, malleable texture similar to dough or clay. Polygel is applied on a nail form or tip, then shaped and filed once it hardens. It air dries – no UV lamps needed.

Polygel provides a lightweight, flexible extension that looks and feels natural on the nails. It resists cracks or breaks, instead flexing if impacted. Available in clear and natural nude colors, it offers a discreet extension.

Polygel Pros

  • Lightweight and comfortable to wear
  • Durable and flexible – resists breaks
  • Air dries for easy application
  • Creates a natural nail look
  • Allows for shaping and customization
  • Easy to learn for beginners

Polygel Cons

  • Can be prone to lifting and shrinking
  • Needs more filing and shaping than hard gels
  • Surface can develop ridges or bubbles
  • Lower odor tolerance than other gels

Polygel gives you control over the extension’s shape and length while remaining flexible and comfy on your natural nails.

Soft Gel

Soft gel has a thick, pudding-like texture and stays flexible when cured. It is applied on the natural nail or on a tip, then shaped as desired. Soft gel cures quickly under UV or LED lamps.

Soft gel provides a glossy, flawless finish that lends itself beautifully to nail art. The flexibility allows for shaping without cracking, and it adheres very well to natural nails.

Soft Gel Pros

  • Creates a high-gloss, glass-like finish
  • Flexible formula allows for shaping
  • Superior adhesion properties
  • Ideal for detailed nail art and embellishments
  • Quick 30-60 second cure time
  • Can extend length or used for overlays

Soft Gel Cons

  • Requires expert skill to shape and apply
  • Glossy finish can look more artificial
  • Not as durable or thick as other gels
  • Needs frequent fills to maintain shape
  • Shrinkage and lifting can occur over time
  • Can damage natural nail if improperly applied

With proper training, soft gel allows you to sculpt beautiful nail art designs that can last weeks with minimal chipping or breakage.

What is Building gels?

Builder gel is an open term that can describe both a soft gel and a hard gel. In some cases builder gel may refer to a hard gel and in others to a soft gel.

But in general, Builder Gels are gels used to rebuild nails by lengthening them or making them thicker.

Durability and Longevity

When it comes to durability:

  • Hard gel is the most durable option – it resists chips and scratches
  • Polygel is flexible yet fairly strong against breaks
  • Soft gel is the least durable – it can break more easily

For longevity:

  • Soft gel and polygel last 2-3 weeks on average
  • Hard gel lasts slightly longer at 3-4 weeks
  • Proper application and nail prep impacts longevity

So hard gel wins for durability while all three offer similar longevity potential.

Ideal User for Each Gel

Ideal User for Each Gel

Polygel Users

Polygel works best for:

  • Beginners new to sculpted extensions
  • Those wanting a light, comfortable extension
  • People desiring shaping and length versatility
  • Seeking a discreet, natural-looking set
  • Prefer a thinner, flexible extension

Soft Gel Users

Soft gel is ideal for:

  • Experienced nail artists and clients
  • Those wanting ultra high-gloss finishes
  • If you enjoy intricate nail art and embellishments
  • Seeking soft yet durable extensions
  • Love having creative freedom over shaping

Hard Gel Users

Hard gel suits:

  • People wanting an ultra durable manicure
  • Beginners looking for an easy application
  • If you prefer gel polish vs sculpting
  • Seeking protective overlays vs length
  • Desire a hard finish that resists damage
  • Prefer a set that requires less shaping

Choosing the Right Gel for You

When deciding between polygel vs soft gel vs hard gel, consider factors like:

  • Your lifestyle and activity level
  • Desired nail shaping and length
  • Skill level and experience with gel
  • Preferences for durability vs flexibility
  • Finish and look you want to achieve

Many people enjoy the versatility of maintaining different gel sets for variety! Try out each gel type to determine which you prefer.

Caring for Gel Nails

To maximize the life of any gel manicure:

  • Use cuticle oil daily to hydrate the nail area
  • Avoid picking at the gel or your cuticles
  • Protect hands from chemicals, impacts, and moisture
  • See your manicurist promptly for any needed fixes
  • Book fills every 2-3 weeks to maintain the set

Which is easier to apply – Polygel or Hard Gel?

I have used both Polygel and Hard Gel for years now and in my opinion Polygel is much easier to apply than hard gel, especially if you are new to either product now.

Polygel has a thicker consistency similar to acrylic that is easier to sculpt because it stays in place better and won’t move unless you move it. While hard gel has a liquid consistency that is more difficult to control and work with.

The thick consistency of Polygel also allows it to be applied using double plastic forms. Using Dual Forms is amazing because it’s one of the quickest ways to create extensions because they don’t require a lot of filing.

Additionally, due to its thick consistency, Polygel applies much faster than Hard Gel. Hard Gel will generally need to be applied in layers and each layer must be cured. While polygel can be applied in a single bead and then cured.

Video – How to use Polygel with Dual Forms

Which will last longer – Polygel or Hard Gel?

In my experience, Hard gels tend to last longer than Polygel but this will vary greatly depending on the brands used. Some brands of Polygel are extremely durable and can easily match hard gels.

Hard gel tends to resist impact better and is less likely to warp because it is harder and more rigid and is less likely to be affected by things like wear and tear, chemicals and heat. Polygel is softer and certain activities like constant typing or tapping will lose its shape. Polygel is also more prone to peeling and fading.

The advantage of Polygel is that it is more flexible and less likely to break when bent, while hard gel is more rigid and hard, making it more likely to break. Polygel is also less likely to lift because it flexes and stays with your natural nails.

Which is easier to remove?

Polygel will be easier to remove than hard/builder gels. All hard gels need to be filed down and usually with an electric nail file. They cannot be removed with acetone.

Some Polygel marks can be removed using acetone or filing. But some brands will have to be classified. Fortunately, Polgel tends to be softer and easier to remove than Hard Gel.

You can click here to read How to Remove Polygel at Home

Which one feels and looks best?

Once applied correctly, Polygel and Hard Gel will be identical and you will not be able to tell the difference between the two.

Now, in my experience, Polygel tends to look more natural. I guess it’s because Polygel is more flexible, allowing it to bend and conform to your natural nails.

However, this will vary considerably depending on the brand of Polygel you use.

Hard Gel, on the other hand, is very rigid and rigid, so it will not flex or move with your nails. This gives it a more artificial feeling.

Conclusion

In the ever-evolving world of nail enhancement, Polygel, soft gel, and hard gel have each earned their places in the spotlight. Polygel boasts the best of both worlds, marrying the flexibility of soft gels with the robustness of hard gels. Its adaptability makes it ideal for a diverse range of nail shapes and lengths. On the other hand, soft gels are perfect for those seeking a natural look with added resilience, while hard gels cater to those desiring long-lasting and durable nail enhancements. Ultimately, the choice hinges on individual needs and preferences. To delve deeper into the unique properties and benefits of each, don’t miss out on our comprehensive guide on the Villa Nails blog. Read more and discover the perfect fit for your nails.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *